And so say all of us ??
That's frightening. It's the kind of support Mussolini got. I don't expect Howard will be handing out brown shirts at the next election, but he is enacting some of the same kinds of laws that got Mussolini elected and kept him in office long past his use-by date.
I do wonder, though, how the poll was framed. For instance, if the question was something like "do you support the police secretly detaining and locking up a terrorist without charge?", there will be a lot of undiscerning and busy folk saying "sure". But if the question was "do you support the police secretly detaining and locking up an innocent person who has not commited any crime without charge?", I would hope if not expect that the results would be entirely different, even though the laws could be used in either case. You can influence the answer by how you frame the question, as has been discussed here before: http://guambatstew.blogspot.com/2005/09/but-what-is-question.html. And you can be reporting and leading public opinion and debate with wholly deceptive statistics in the process.
Labels: Politics of fear
4 Comments:
Yeah, I agree with you about how the poll questions can be framed. The anti-terror legislation has been public for about ten days now, so it is still quite new.
Another point might be with the use of the word 'terrorist'. Of course people would support laws to stop any real terrorist, but this legislation is not about terrorists, but about 'suspected' terrorists. Even then there is no solid evidence involved with the exercise of these laws. In another time such laws may have been about 'suspected' communists, or 'suspected' witches.
Once people start to think about the indescriminate way such laws can be used, and the possibility of friends and family being detained without any recourse at all, I think that the polls will turn around - and very quickly actually.
Howard knows that he has to sneak the laws through parliament as quickly as possible.
Perhaps if we declare ASIO a terrorist organisation it could imprison itself without charge?
"Once people start to think about the indescriminate way such laws can be used, and the possibility of friends and family being detained without any recourse at all, I think that the polls will turn around - and very quickly actually." -- Sure hope you're right on this one, Pharoz.
Guambat
Über-Kiwi,
I don't really think ASIO is the problem, though how could any of us know for sure. My best hunch is this is a political game. So, go straight to the source: http://guambatstew.blogspot.com/2005/10/as-i-see-it-john-howard-is-terrorist.html
Thanks for the comment,
Guambat
Post a Comment
<< Home